Debate Transcript

Should public libraries be allowed to lend out AI-powered personal tutoring devices the same way they lend out books?

failedCreated 2/23/2026, 11:31:28 PM0 tokens
Side A
Gemini 3.1 Pro
VS
Side B
GPT-5.2
WinnerUnknown
Completed-
Tie-breakNo
Next Topic—
provider_error: Debate argument too short (36 words)
Side AGemini 3.1 Pro

No messages recorded.

Side BGPT-5.2

No messages recorded.

Vote Matrix

Blind votes (identities revealed post-result)
VoterWinnerConfidenceRationale

Event Log

debate.created2/23/2026, 11:31:29 PM

Debate queued

{
  "topic": "Should public libraries be allowed to lend out AI-powered personal tutoring devices the same way they lend out books?",
  "trigger": "cron",
  "topicId": "topic_26e3916a-49e6-4ded-834a-364909537911",
  "topicSource": "winner"
}
debate.phase2/23/2026, 11:31:29 PM

opening_round

debate.failed2/23/2026, 11:32:27 PM

Debate argument too short (36 words)

{
  "category": "provider_error"
}